By Natalie Beck
In the 1989 classic film Uncle Buck, written and directed by John Hughes, Midwestern values come to life in this comedy set in the outskirts of Chicago. Filmed primarily in Evanston, Illinois as well as other suburbs and even the city of Chicago, this film subtly captures a Midwestern feel. With John Candy playing “Buck,” the wacky uncle that is estranged from the family, Midwestern values on the family come to life in nothing short of a hilarious good time.
At the onset of the movie, the audience is introduced to a typical Midwestern family of five, with two daughters and a son. The eldest daughter, Tia, plays the role of a difficult teenager, often giving her parents, especially her mother a hard time. One of the earliest examples of this is when the family is gathered around the dinner table eating Chinese food. Tia sarcastically turns to her mother and says, “Oh Mother, however did you cook this delicious meal?” Her mother immediately stares back at her, visibly weary of what the audience assumes is a long struggle between mother and teenage daughter. This scene sets the stage for continuing conflict with Tia and other members of the family, including Uncle Buck.
However, Tia’s cold and sarcastic attitude is quickly explained when it is mentioned that the family moved away from the mother’s side of the family to Chicago because of an opportunity for more money. Tia is clearly the most affected by this move, and it is clear that family values run strong throughout the Midwest if even teenagers are affected by the loss of family. What is even more striking in this sense of loss in Tia is the fact that Tia never once mentions moving away from friends, leaving her old house or neighborhood, or even school. She only references the loss of family members from the move.
In the first plot twist of the movie, the mother received a phone call that her father has had a heart attack. She must go to Indianapolis to see him, and once Tia finds out that her grandfather has had a heart attack, she is very upset. The mother says, “I love my father very much,” and Tia’s response is, “Then why did you move away from him? If my whole family moved away from me, I would have a heart attack, too.” While this is an incredibly harsh response to her grieving mother, it is very clear that this is the response of a girl who misses her family and sees value in being in close proximity to loved ones, comparing a move with a heart attack. This scene also sets up the movie to show that Tia is not just going through a normal teenage angst period, but is actually suffering. With this established so early on, it forces the audience to want to see some sort of resolution come for this character.
This scene also sets up the mother and father to be vulnerable and distressed, which they appropriately are. As the mother and father prepare to leave for Indianapolis, they search through their rolodex for people who can watch the kids. The parents are shown communicating with one another and brain storming different names of who they could call. None of the suggestions are family members until the father suggests, “Hey, what about my brother Buck?” The suggestion is immediately shot down because of Buck’s irresponsibility, but resurfaces after the parents realize they have no one they can turn to in a time of need. This is the point when the mother says, “I am so helpless here.” This is the first time that the audience sees the mother equally upset about the move. This is solidified when her husband convinces her not to get down about the move “again,” signifying that the move has been a hard transition for everyone in the family, because of the loss of their family members.
Within the first few scenes of the movie, Uncle Buck already hits the nail on the head with the importance of family values in the Midwest. Family is not just about staying connected with one another through the internet or over the phone, but is about living in community with one another. Family represents part of everyday life. In reality, for other areas of the country, a move equivalent to the Indianapolis to Chicago move would not be considered a significant move, being only a few hours. However, to Midwestern families, this move is a life-altering decision that leaves families recuperating from the blow.
Eventually, once the parents realize they have to leave and they have no other options, they call Buck. In this scene, it is clear that Buck and his brother are estranged, but that their connection is still genuine. Buck is more than happy to help out. It is clear that Buck is considered a nut case, but that he is still family, and family is all that matters. It is comical to watch the scene where the brothers interact over the phone because the audience knows that the entire plot of the movie was probably created off of the idea of that one crazy, estranged uncle every Midwestern family has. The uncle that everyone knows is unreliable, who is not put together, and may be a little slow in development, but that is still an uncle.
Buck as a Midwestern character is an interesting concept in and of itself. He is clearly a take on a cliché, being unmarried, unemployed, and unmotivated. He even just so happens to live by Wrigley Field, which only adds to this Midwestern character. Watching him reminds me of my uncles and their undying loyalty to Chicago teams, through thick and thin, despite where they move or how bad the team is.
Buck also brings in another interesting character into the movie, and that is Chanice, his love interest. Chanice is much more put together. She has a job, she is responsible, and she wants to get married. She sticks with Buck, even when he is a disappointment, and tries to help pull him together. She embodies the Midwestern values of hard work, while also emphasizing the Midwestern values of family because she wants her own with Buck. She is a nice balance to the figure of Buck, who is rough around the edges and loves his life as a bachelor.
Once Buck agrees to come to the family’s house in the suburbs, the comical scenes start flowing like water. Buck’s crude attitudes pair nicely with his allegiance to his family, often times showing him as a strong protective figure, whether or not his nieces and nephews want it. Within his first few days at the house, Buck manages to put the fear of God into Tia’s boyfriend, confronts Maizy’s principal, who believes Maizy is too much of a dreamer at the age of seven, and punches a clown that shows up to Miles’ birthday party drunk. Buck tries by whatever means necessary to help maintain a happy environment for his nieces and nephews.
Some of the scenes show Buck as a good caretaker, such as when he makes gigantic pancakes for Miles’ birthday. Other times, however, the family life is shown as having a positive influence on Buck. In many of the scenes, he is shown having to do laundry, as well as cook and clean. These are standard caretaker chores that he takes on, but it isn’t until he has to go to the race track to place bets that the true effects of family life have rubbed off on him. Tia runs off to a weekend long party at a friend’s house, leaving Miles and Maizy at the house under Buck’s sole care. Buck has no choice but to take the two children if he wants to make it to the track in time, but before he pulls out of the driveway, he stares back at the two children and realizes that he can’t go through with it. He can’t be a bad influence on his young family members. This is the scene where Buck develops into a responsible adult from a wild, goofy bachelor. Buck calls Chanice for help with the kids, and the audience has a double impact of this scene because of Chanice’s surprised reaction to Buck’s new sense of responsibility.
Buck manages to make it to the party where Buck thinks Tia is with her boyfriend, Bug. By the time Buck makes it to the party, however, Tia has already left because of a fight with Bug. Buck drives up along side Tia walking down the street and offers her a ride. Rather than having another fight like they have been having throughout the movie, Buck consoles her and allows her to be upset about the situation with Bug. This moment is heart-felt and surprisingly sweet for a movie that is predominantly full of jokes and ridiculous humor, with Buck saying that he is really glad he got to known Tia and wants to have a relationship with her. Tia feels the same way, and the scene would be overly sentimental if it wasn’t for the abrupt change in pace when Tia asks what Buck did to Bug.
The scene cuts to Buck opening his trunk and revealing a gagged and bound Bug, screaming for help. Buck forces Bug to apologize to Tia, switching back into his role as protective uncle. Bug apologizes and Buck lets him go. However, as Buck drives away, Bug screams at him from what he thinks is a safe distance. Buck reverses the car and gets a golf club and golf balls out of his trunk. He takes aim and smacks Bug with the balls, one after the other.
While this scene is absolutely hilarious, it does hit on some very real values, which is that family always comes first. Many Midwestern women can attest to the fact that they have at least one crazy family member, an uncle or an aunt, a brother or maybe even a grandparent, who has no bounds for where familial ties and loyalty end. For these family members, no one messes with their family members. For the Russell family, Buck is just that guy. He is so loyal to Tia, that he is willing to take practice swings at an ex-boyfriend.
By the end of the movie, Tia and Buck have called a cease fire and a truce. The younger niece and nephew have fully bonded with buck, and Buck himself has grown and matured, much to the pleasure of Chanice. However, these were not the only character relationships that needed fixing. From the very beginning of the movie, it was clear that Tia and her mother had a strained relationship that was hard for both involved. This relationship, with the help of Buck, and a new found security in family life, is able to be reclaimed at the end of the movie.
The reunion between Tia and her mother happens as the mother and father come back from Indianapolis. Tia is waiting in the hallway while Buck, Chanice, Miles, and Maizy hide in the kitchen. The mother is the first person to walk through the door, and a long stare is held between her and Tia. No words are exchanged; Tia merely walks up to her mother and abruptly hugs her. The tension between the two is cut in half and the father walks in as the mother is letting out sighs of relief and gasps of joy. The final seal on the deal is when the mother says, “It’s going to be a lot different.”
The mere fact that the entire plot can be brought together by a reunion of a mother and a daughter is clearly Midwestern in value. Resolution within the family is the highest relief of stress for the audience, and plot tension is gone. The scene ends with comical relief from Buck, who knocks over pots and pans, but even the comedy cannot overshadow the climatic scene with Tia and her mother.
At the very end of the movie, Chanice and Buck leave the house as the family says their goodbyes. Buck has found himself in the good graces of the Russell’s and with Chanice, because of his newfound maturity. As he is about to leave, he says to Tia, “Hey, maybe next time you’re downtown, maybe we can go get a coffee or something.” Tia smiles and agrees, showing a very different Tia from the very beginning of the movie who was cold and sarcastic.
In general, this scene seems to show that the only remedy for Tia’s loss of family is to find new family to unite with. No new friends or boyfriends could replace family members for this teenager, or for the entire Russell family. The movie seems to suggest that even the oddball uncle can bring together a broken family, making things better. But Midwesterners know that it isn’t about an oddball uncle coming in to save the day, but about family members coming together to form bonds that are so essential to the Midwestern way of life. As a Midwesterner myself, I can testify that nothing can replace family, except maybe more family.
Redemption and Americanism in Gran Torino
Tuesday, November 20th, 2012Raber Aziz
Redemption
Walt Kowalski, Clint Eastwood, is an old school Korean War veteran who has lost his faith in the war where he seemingly killed people and committed crimes as well as he argues with the priest, Father Janovich, played by Christopher Carley, that what bothers him about the war was not what he was ordered to do but the things he did that he was “not ordered to do”. The burden of what he did in the Korean War has been on his mind ever since and he does not find peace in anything. The death of his beloved wife, Dorothy, has just added to his restlessness, therefore he is seeking peace especially after the death of his wife he becomes worried about his own life.
Basically, this is what Clint Eastwood’s 2008 movie, Gran Torino – Eastwood’s second self directed project after the 2004 Million Dollar Baby – is about: redemption of a war veteran. The theme of redemption is noticed throughout the movie. The movie opens with Kowalski standing, in a church, by the coffin of his beloved wife, Dorothy, who has recently passed away. People come forth to offer condolences to Kowalski for the loss of his wife and to pay their final homage to his late wife. The priest preaches that “death is a bittersweet occasion to us Catholics. Bitter in the pain, sweet in salvation.” But these words, which serve as the first warning to Kowalski to seek redemption before it is too late, mean little for him who has seen a lot of deaths in the Korean war and because of which he has lost his faith. He has stopped going to church to confess his sins long time ago. In fact, he never really “cared very much for the church” and only went because of his wife. He has no desire to confess especially to a young priest. Father Janovich is persistent, however. He always pops up out of nowhere to remind Kowalski to go to church and confess his sins. A proud tough guy, Kowalski is not convinced easily, especially by a 27-year-old priest who is, in Kowalski’s view “an over educated… virgin who would like to take the hands of old ladies who were superstitious and promises them eternity”.
As the movie goes on and Kowalski starts to build relationships with his Hmong neighbors, especially with Sue, acted by Ahney Her, and Thao, Bee Vang, following the latter’s attempt to steal Kowalski’s Gran Torino, other reminders of redemption come his way. Kowalski is sitting at the front of his door with his dog. He reads the newspaper horoscope which goes: “It is your birthday… This year, you will have to make a choice between two life paths. Second chances come your way”. This is the second reminder Kowalski gets in the movie in order to redeem for his sins, but “what a load of shit” it is to the old school tough guy Kowalski who needs more than just a priest’s appeal and a newspaper horoscope to convince him to take the path to redemption by confessing his sins at the confessional and go back to the grace of his lord. He tries to find peace, instead, in teaching Thao how to “be a man”, helping him find a job, lending him money to buy his tools, and in protecting the neighborhood. But he can’t find peace, not only because he can’t forget the past and the “horrible things” he has done in the war, but also because the Asian gang is disturbing the peace of the whole neighborhood about which he will have to do something someday.
As the plot of the movie develops, Kowalski’s relationship with his Hmong friends, particularly Sue and Thao becomes stronger. One day, he decides to join his celebrating neighbors, and perhaps because of the abundance of “gook food” rather than socializing. He is there sitting on a chair finding himself in front of a Hmong priest, or fortuneteller, who wants to read his fortune, Kowalski agrees. While Sue translates, the priest tells Kowalski that he is a man who does not get the respect he deserves, that he is a person who is worried about his life, and that he made mistakes that he regrets and because of that he has no happiness in his life. This time, the third reminder for redemption, Kowalski is moved by the Hmong priest’s words. He gets up out of his seat and leaves.
What finally settles Kowalski’s inner conflict to come over his stubbornness, pride and despair that he is not redeemable is when he finds out that the Asian gang has abducted Sue, beat her and raped her. Feeling guilty for what happened to Sue because he beat a member of the Asian gang for hurting Thao, Kowalski decides to redeem for his sins. One morning, Kowalski moans his garden, takes a hot bath, has a haircut, buys a new suit then goes to church to confess. He has finally thrown away the burden he felt because of his war actions. But the peace e has found seems to only cover his past sins from the Korean War as far as the point when Sue was kidnapped, beaten and raped because of his action. And for that he will have to seek redemption in a different way, to do something whereby Sue, Thao and the whole neighborhood will never see any trouble from the Asian gang again. He decides to face the gang head on. Standing in front of the house where the gang live, he acts as if he has a gun. He takes out a cigarette and puts it in his mouth, “you got a lighter?” he asks while reaching for his lighter in his pocket in a way that the gang think he is actually reaching for his gun and at which point they open fire on him and kill him on the spot. Kowalski lays there on the ground with his legs stretched and his arms wide open as if on a cross. He has redeemed for all his sins by offering his own life as the ultimate sacrifice for the good of the neighborhood and his Hmong neighbors. He has found salvation for himself, peace for his neighbourhood. Kowalski does not stop there, he has also written a will in which he has given away the house to the church in honor of his wife’s wish for him to confess his sins and has given the Gran Torino to his Hmong friend Thao in whom Kowalski saw a good young man.
Americanism
While Gran Torino is a movie of redemption; it is also a movie of Americanism. Kowalski is very proud of his American values; he maintains his property well, moans the garden often and keeps everything in order. He is very proud of his American made 1972 Gran Torino and prefers it to other foreign made cars even though American cars might be more expensive than Japanese cars or even if they are less fuel efficient than other foreign vehicles. Following the end of the mourning of Kowalski’s wife, we see him looking with discontent at his son’s Japanese made Toyota Land Cruiser as he passes by him. “Would it kill you if you buy American?” he murmurs to himself referring to his son’s choice of car. Kowalski’s Gran Torino represents his American spirit. It represents the superiority of the American industry, the American muscle, and the American values and therefore he takes good care of it, washes it often and cares for it like a human being. He even personifies it as a woman. “ain’t she a beauty?” he says to himself when he sits in his chair on the porch admiringly looking at his car that has just been washed clean and parked just outside of his garage.
Walt Kowalski acts in many ways as a coach to Thao as the two get close to each other. We see Kowalski teach Thao how to repair house roofs, how to be a man and talk like a man in order to leave a good impression, and even how to deal with girls. When Kowalski has Thao for a week to put him to work as a punishment for his attempt to steal the Gran Torino, Kowalski finds him some useful work to do so that not only he realizes that he made a mistake, but also learns from the punishment some useful skills that would later prove very useful when he takes him to his friend who works on the construction site in order to find a job for him. Kowalski shows Thao how to work hard and build his own life with his own hands. Amazed at the number of tools and gadgets Kowalski kept in his garage, Thao asks where Kowalski got all the tools from. That might be a surprise to a thief, but I bought every tool in here with my own money, he replied with sarcasm. He also finds him a job, buys him construction tools with his own money just to put him to work so he can learn to depend on himself. Kowalski also teaches Thao how to speak like men. He shows him how to speak with respect but also never “kiss ass”. And we also see Kowalski teach Thao how to treat girls when they are interested in him and he has the same feeling. The way is not to stand off and look on from a distance. Thao needs to ask “Yum-Yum” out like any man does when he is interested in a woman. He encourages Thao to do that or he is going to ask the Asian girl out himself, he tells Thao and the girl. He does not stop there, only giving advice, he lets Thao take his own majestic Gran Torino in order to make their first date important and romantic.
Kowalski is the typical American hero who fights alone even when others are ready to help, when it is possible to just call the police and let them handle the situation, or when it is not his problem yet he is ready to fight the evil and to sacrifice himself for others. He is committed to justice. When the Hmong gang assigns Thao, who are not yet friends with Kowalski, with stealing his Gran Torino, Kowalski finds out that someone is in his garage trying to steal from him. He could have easily called police and let them catch the boy and handle the situation, but he decided to take action right away without calling police. He takes out his old gun, probably his Korean War rifle, and heads directly to his garage to get his thief. It is not Kowalski’s way to call police for such issues; this is simply not the American hero’s way to handle situations, at least no in movies. He handles them on his own. He is a macho man and a veteran soldier who has seen war and death. Again, when the Hmong gang block Thao’s way, take away his construction tools and beat him, put out a cigarette on his face, Kowalski decides to take action on his own even though Thao tells him that “It is not your problem” to do anything about it, but he does not listen to that, he is dedicated to fighting the evil. Kowalski goes alone to the gang’s place and beat one of them so hard that he hurts his own hand. Again when Sue walks with a white guy in an apparently black neighborhood, Kowalski is there to stand up against three young black men in order to save Sue even though he and Sue were not friends yet. And we see in the end that Kowalski sacrifices himself for his neighborhood in order to put an end to the troubles the gang cause for the Hmong community when he faces the gang in front of their own place and without even a gun. His plan is to get himself killed by the gang while the whole neighborhood looks on so that everybody in the community who watched the incident could testify against the gang when police started investigating and took statements from eyewitnesses and thus the gang will be found guilty and put to jail probably forever.
Posted in Commentary on Texts and Lectures, Film | Comments Off